Global Ethics Corner: Disaster, Decline, or Rebirth: A Japanese Fish Story

Apr 29, 2011

Japan's recent tsunami and nuclear disaster have devastated its fishing industry. Fish are at the heart of Japanese culture, yet worldwide stocks of wild fish are in drastic descent. Should there be a push to revive this occupation or should Japan be trying to grow new industries?

Tragedies are the core stories after the disasters in Japan. Containing nuclear destruction is the ongoing drama.

A smaller, but instructive, tale surrounds the Japanese fishing industry. Rarely is something central to a nation's psyche overthrown in a moment.

Fish and rice are at the heart of Japanese culture and fishing is mythical to this island nation. The International Herald Tribune notes that Japanese "eat more fish per capita than people in any other developed country..." "The importance of fishing...in Japanese culture belies the fishing industries status in the economy."

Fishing is a declining occupation. Worldwide stocks of wild fish are in drastic descent, and species are increasingly fished to the brink of extinction. Consequent competition on the high seas is ever more intense.

Globally, industries rise and fall, carrying peoples' livelihoods and entire communities with them. In America the demise of steel, sugar cane, and small farming devastated regions. The misery of decline, fall, and renewal takes generations, and success is far from certain.

For much of the Japanese fishing industry, the twin disasters wiped the slate clean. But, what's next?

The push of old, core values is strong. Some know nothing but challenging the oceans for food, while for others, the fishing industry sustains national symbols, and requires renewed investment.

The pull of new visions is also powerful. Decline was overthrown by disaster offering a chance to rapidly reinvent a region, to grow new industries.

What would you do, rebuild the strengths of the past or focus on rebirth? Resources may not allow both.

By William Vocke

For more information see:

Stuart Biggs, Kanoko Matusuyama, Frederik Balfour, "For Already Waning Japanese Fishing Industry, A Possible Knockout Blow," The International Herald Tribune, April 26, 2011, p. 20.

Photo Credits in order of Appearance:

Matthias Lambrecht
Takeshi Igarashi
Annonymous
Joran Pecher
Gilson Higashi

Danielle Hams
Walt Hubis
Marius Watz
Devon Adams
Matthew M. Bradley/ U.S. Navy

Mike Bostock
Matthias Lambrecht
Matthias Lambrecht

You may also like

NOV 21, 2024 Article

A New International Order Is Emerging, We Must Bring Our Principles With Us

On the heels of a new international order, Carnegie Council will continue to champion the vision of peace and cooperation that remains our mission.

NOV 13, 2024 Article

An Ethical Grey Zone: AI Agents in Political Deliberations

As adoption of agentic AI increases, it is critical for researchers and policymakers to agree on ethical principles to inform governance of this emerging technology.

OCT 24, 2024 Article

Artificial Intelligence and Election Integrity in 2024

This final project from the first CEF cohort discusses the effects of AI on election integrity as billions of people go to the polls in 2024.

No traducido

Este contenido aún no ha sido traducido a su idioma. Puede solicitar una traducción haciendo clic en el botón de abajo.

Solicitar traducción