Global Ethics Corner: U.S. Elections and World Opinion

Oct 17, 2008

Should the opinions of the world be important in American elections? This is a crucial question in applied ethics as we choose a president.

Should the opinions of the world be important in American elections? This is a crucial question in applied ethics as we choose a president. Let's frame the question as two poles.

First, the choice of the president is the single most important decision in international relations. The president makes decisions that immediately and directly impact everyone, affecting the deployment of the world's most powerful military; global growth; or the stability of the international financial system. Others have a stake in this choice. Furthermore, America is integrated globally through economics, the environment, and basic human values. Of the many criteria for choosing a president, judging candidates by their global impact is a prerequisite of the 21st century.


The polar position is that U.S. elections are about America. Voters are not obligated to look abroad. Americans need to take care of business at home. International problems can't be mended while downplaying domestic issues. Deploying the military should depend on America's security needs, not on others' interests. When our financial system requires overhaul, the primary objective should be ensuring American (and hence global) prosperity. Candidates need to be judged by their ability to be effective American presidents. Then, they can also be global leaders.

Your views may be somewhere in the middle, but this polarity suggests an important choice.

By William Vocke

To post a comment, go to the Global Ethics Corner slideshow.

You may also like

Left to Right: Ann Curry, Ben Loeterman, Emma Belcher, Joel Rosenthal. CREDIT: Bryan Goldberg Photogrpahy.

MAY 22, 2026 Video

Nuclear Ethics

This "Values & Interests" panel discussion, held in partnership with PBS and moderated by acclaimed journalist Ann Curry, is available to view in full.

Joel Rosenthal and James Story.

MAY 1, 2026 Video

U.S. Power and Principle

James Story, former U.S. ambassador to Venezuela, visits Carnegie Council to discuss the new dynamic between American power and principle.

United States Capitol at sunrise. CREDIT: Andy Feliciotti/Unsplash.

AUG 5, 2025 Report

Illiberal Narratives and Shifting Values: Examining Competing Visions of the U.S. and its Role in the World

This report examines the rise of illiberal narratives in U.S foreign policy and the recent dismantling of American soft power institutions.

No traducido

Este contenido aún no ha sido traducido a su idioma. Puede solicitar una traducción haciendo clic en el botón de abajo.

Solicitar traducción