Ethics & International Affairs Volume 13 (1999): Special Section: Amnesty Justice and Reconciliation: Reconciliation for Realists [Abstract]

Dec 4, 1999

Reconciliation is being urged upon people who have been bitter and murderous enemies, upon victims and perpetrators of terrible human rights abuses, and upon groups of individuals whose very self-conceptions have been structured in terms of historical and often state-sanctioned relations of dominance and submission. The rhetoric of reconciliation is particularly common in situations where traditional judicial responses to past wrongdoing are unavailable because of corruption in the legal system, staggeringly large numbers of offenders, or anxiety about the political consequences of trials and punishment. But what is reconciliation? How is reconciliation to be achieved? And under what conditions should it be sought?

The notable lack of answers to these questions prompts the worry that talk of reconciliation is merely a ruse to disguise the fact that a "purer" type of justice cannot be realized--that, in being asked to focus on reconciliation rather than on punishment, victims of past wrongdoing are having to settle for the morally second best. By mining our pretheoretical understandings of reconciliation, the essay arrives at a core concept of reconciliation as narrative incorporation that at the same time suggests a way in which reconciliation might be pursued and grounds a response to moral qualms provoked by the use of an unanalyzed conception of reconciliation.

To read or purchase the full text of this article, click here.

You may also like

Joel Rosenthal & David Sacks. CREDIT: Simon Myaskovsky.

NOV 16, 2026 • Video

Hans Morgenthau and the Enduring Value of Realism

Access this conversation between Carnegie Council President Joel Rosenthal and David Sacks, author of "The Realist: Hans Morgenthau and the Purpose of American Power."

Robert D. Kaplan & Stephen D. Hibbard. CREDIT: Simon Myaskovsky.

NOV 10, 2026 • Video

Getting China Right: The Ultimate Moral Dilemma

How can the U.S. avoid miscalculating when it comes to China? Access the Third Charles W. Kegley, Jr. Annual Lecture with Robert D. Kaplan.

NOV 6, 2026 • Podcast

Moral Courage, Individual Agency, and Institutional Trust

Former FBI special agent Asha Rangappa joins “Values & Interests” to discuss the ethical challenges facing public servants in an era of eroding institutional norms.

No traducido

Este contenido aún no ha sido traducido a su idioma. Puede solicitar una traducción haciendo clic en el botón de abajo.

Solicitar traducción